|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 53-59
In vitro evaluation of coronal discoloration following the application of calcium-enriched mixture cement, Biodentine, and mineral trioxide aggregate in endodontically treated teeth
Solmaz Araghi1, Atefeh Khavid2, Mostafa Godiny3, Mahshid Saeidipour4
1 Department of Endodontics, Islamic Azad University, Dental Branch, Tehran, Iran
2 Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran
3 Department of Endodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran
4 Student Research Committee, Dental School, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran
|Date of Web Publication||7-Jan-2019|
Dr. Mostafa Godiny
Department of Endodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: This study sought to assess and compare coronal discoloration following the application of white mineral trioxide aggregate, Biodentine, and calcium-enriched mixture cement in endodontically treated teeth.
Materials and Methods: In this in vitro experimental study, 64 freshly extracted sound human premolars were selected, cleaned, and stored in saline. After cleaning, shaping, and obturation the root canal of the teeth, the teeth were randomly assigned to one control (n = 4) and three experimental (n = 20) groups. In the experimental groups, the cement were applied over the canal orifices in 3-mm thickness. All teeth were then restored with composite resin. Color parameters, according to the CIE L*a*b* system, were measured using Vita Easyshade spectrophotometer before application of cement and at 1 week, 1 month, 2 months, and 3 months after the application of cement. The recorded values were statistically analyzed using descriptive and analytical statistics. For analytical statistics, Kolmogorov–Smirnov test was applied to assess normal distribution of data. ANOVA was used to compare the results at baseline and repeated measures. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant
Results: Significant differences were noted in color change (ΔE) between all time points except between ΔE4 (2 months) and ΔE5 (3 months) (P < 0.01). However, tooth discoloration caused by the three cement was not significantly different (P = 0.343).
Conclusion: The three tested cement were not significantly different in terms of causing coronal discoloration in endodontically treated teeth.
Keywords: Mineral trioxide aggregate, root canal filling materials, spectrophotometry, tooth discoloration
|How to cite this article:|
Araghi S, Khavid A, Godiny M, Saeidipour M. In vitro evaluation of coronal discoloration following the application of calcium-enriched mixture cement, Biodentine, and mineral trioxide aggregate in endodontically treated teeth. Dent Res J 2019;16:53-9
|How to cite this URL:|
Araghi S, Khavid A, Godiny M, Saeidipour M. In vitro evaluation of coronal discoloration following the application of calcium-enriched mixture cement, Biodentine, and mineral trioxide aggregate in endodontically treated teeth. Dent Res J [serial online] 2019 [cited 2020 Aug 8];16:53-9. Available from: http://www.drjjournal.net/text.asp?2019/16/1/53/249550
| Introduction|| |
Dental pulp is composed of ectomesenchymal connective tissue with unique properties. If for any reason the pulp tissue loses its vitality, new dentin formation is impaired and the tooth becomes highly susceptible to infection. In case of dental pulp injury, depending on the extent of injury and pulp vitality status, some measures may need to be taken. Correct clinical judgment and proper treatment planning play a significant role in prognosis and outcome of treatment. If patients are not satisfied with the outcome of treatment, they need to invest more time and money to obtain the desired result.
Several materials have been introduced to dental market to improve the quality of endodontic treatments such as calcium hydroxide, zinc oxide eugenol, different types of mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) cement, Endocem, Biodentine,, glass ionomer, and calcium-enriched mixture (CEM) cement. These products can use as orifice obturator and repair the perforation. An ideal endodontic cement must be able to seal root canal communications with the surrounding tissue and should be nontoxic, noncarcinogenic, biocompatible, and insoluble in tissue fluids.
Discoloration of tooth structure secondary to the use of endodontic cement is currently the most common concern with regard to endodontic treatment with a frequency of 31.6%–57%., This complication has been documented in many previous studies.,, Thus, in selection of an endodontic cement, esthetic considerations must be taken into account in addition to biological and functional properties. This issue is particularly important because tooth discoloration, especially in the esthetic zone, causes patient dissatisfaction and necessitates corrective treatments such as prosthetic restorations or tooth bleaching., Thus, clinicians should preferably use endodontic cement with minimal discoloration potential.
MTA is derived from Portland cement and contains small hydrophilic particles, tricalcium silicate, tricalcium aluminate, tricalcium oxide, and some other mineral oxides. It sets in the presence of water, and after setting, it converts to a crystalline gel of calcium silicate hydrate and calcium hydroxide. Furthermore, it contains bismuth in its formulation for radiopacity. MTA is available in two forms of gray and white and wasfirst introduced as a root-end filling material; however, over time, it was used for pulp capping, pulpotomy, apexogenesis, and apical barrier formation in open-apex teeth and root perforations.,
Some studies have reported shortcomings of MTA to be solubility in the saliva, difficult handling, long setting time, absence of a solvent for it, and causing tooth discoloration.,,,, Discoloration of tooth structure following the application of MTA is a common occurrence.,, Bismuth present in the formulation of white and gray MTA is now believed to be responsible for color change in tooth structure.,,
Considering the unfavorable properties of MTA, some other calcium silicate-based cement were introduced. Biodentine is a newly introduced calcium silicate-based cement, which according to the manufacturer, has applications similar to those of MTA and is composed of powder and liquid phases. Biodentine powder is composed of tricalcium silicate, calcium carbonate, and zirconium oxide for radiopacity. Its liquid contains calcium chloride as an accelerator to enhance setting of material and decrease its water content. Biodentine is a fast-setting cement, and it is claimed that it can replace the lost dentin., In acidic environments, it has a superior function compared to that of MTA. Moreover, it has easier handling than MTA. However, Biodentine can also cause tooth discoloration. However, some studies have reported less discoloration following the application of Biodentine compared to MTA.,
CEM cement, recently introduced by Asgary et al., has clinical applications similar to those of MTA but with a different formulation.,, It is claimed that CEM cement is more alkaline than white MTA and thus has superior antimicrobial properties, biocompatibility and sealing ability compared to white MTA. Moreover, it has a shorter setting time and higher flowability compared to MTA.,
Inspection by the naked eye, photography,, spectrophotometry,, and X-ray diffraction analysis have been used for colorimetry in the previous studies. In the current study, color parameters were measured by spectrophotometry since this technique has been approved by the American Dental Association and is the most commonly used technique for this purpose.
Results of previous studies on tooth discoloration caused by CEM cement have been controversial. Previous studies showed that MTA can cause tooth discoloration;,, however, the results of studies on tooth discoloration caused by Biodentine have been controversial. Furthermore, limited studies have evaluated tooth discoloration caused by CEM cement,,, and to the best of authors' knowledge, comparison of CEM cement, Biodentine, and MTA in terms of tooth discoloration has not been previously performed. Thus, it is important to find out which one of these cement causes the least discoloration in endodontically treated teeth.
This study aimed to compare coronal discoloration at varying time points following the application of MTA, CEM cement, and Biodentine in endodontically treated teeth.
| Materials and Methods|| |
In this in vitro study, 64 freshly extracted human premolars with intact crowns were selected. The teeth had been extracted for orthodontic or periodontal reasons, the teeth without any crack, detectable discoloration caries, and restoration were selected and randomly assigned to one control (n = 4) and three experimental (n = 20) groups. Sample size was calculated using PASS 11 software (NCSS LLC Company) according to a previous study by Ioannidis et al.
Preparation of teeth
All teeth were inspected to ensure they had sound crowns and were then subjected to scaling and root planning. In thefirst step, access cavity preparation and working length determination were done. Next, #1, 2, and 3 Gates Glidden (Mani Inc., Japan) drills were passively introduced into the canals. Filing was performed by hand K-files (Mani Inc., Japan) and Mtwo rotary files (VDW, Germany) according to the manufacturer's instructions, and root canals were cleaned and shaped as such. It should be noted that during filing, root canals were frequently irrigated with saline and sodium hypochlorite 0.5%. Prepared root canals were then dried by paper points (Gapadent, Germany) and filled with gutta-percha (Gapadent, Germany) and AH26 sealer (DeTrey, Dentsply, Germany) using lateral compaction technique. Gutta-percha was cut at the orifice level and the teeth were randomly assigned to one control (n = 4) and three experimental (n = 20) groups for application of white MTA (Angelus™, Londrina, Brazil), Biodentine (Septodont, Saint-Maur-des-Fossés, France) and CEM cement (Bionique, Tehran, Iran).
In order to prevent discoloration due to gutta-percha and AH26 sealer, gutta-percha was cut at the level of orifice and pulp chamber was thoroughly cleaned from gutta-percha and sealer residues using a cotton pellet dipped in alcohol.
In all teeth except for the control group, 3 mm of the respective cement were directly applied over the orifice on top of gutta-percha [Figure 1]. Control group did not receive any cement after root canal therapy. After the application of bonding agent (3M ESPE, St. Paul, MN, USA), all teeth were restored with Z250 composite (3M ESPE, St. Paul, MN, USA) with a color shade matching the tooth color [Figure 2]. The teeth were then immersed in saline and stored in a glass container at room temperature under natural lighting. Saline solution was refreshed every 3 days.
Color parameters were measured with a spectrophotometer (Vita EasyShade® compact, VITA Zahnfabrik, Germany) at baseline (before application of cement) and at 1 week, 1 month, 2 months, and 3 months after the application of cement according to the CIE L*a*b* color system. Before each color measurement, the teeth were cleaned and the device was calibrated according to instruction manuals. Tooth color was measured at the mid-buccal area and in room with same light in different times. A mounting jig was used for reproducible position [Figure 3]. According to the manufacturer, the L*, a*, and b* parameters were measured for each tooth by the same observer 3 times and the mean of each value was used to calculate the overall color change using the formula below:
Where L* indicates lightness, Δa* indicates changes in a* parameter in red-green axis, and Δb* indicates changes in b* parameter in yellow–blue axis.
The data were analyzed using SPSS version 18 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). ΔE1 was defined as coronal color change in each group immediately after application of cement compared to baseline (before application of cement). ΔE2, ΔE3, ΔE4, and ΔE5 were defined as coronal color change at 1 week, 1 month, 2 months, and 3 months after the application of cement compared to baseline, respectively [Figure 4].
The data were analyzed using descriptive and analytical statistics. The number, mean, and standard deviation (SD) were reported for descriptive statistics of data. For analytical statistics, Kolmogorov–Smirnov test was applied to assess normal distribution of data. ANOVA was used to compare the results at baseline and repeated-measures ANOVA was applied to compare the four groups and different time points. Pairwise comparisons of the groups and time points were carried out using Bonferroni test.
| Results|| |
Kolmogorov–Smirnov test was applied to assess the normality of data. The results of Kolmogorov–Smirnov test showed that color change data in all groups had normal distribution.
Levene's test was used to assess equality of variances, which showed equality of variances for baseline color change in the groups (P = 0.063). ANOVA was applied to assess the differences in ΔE1 (color change immediately after placement of materials) among the groups, which showed a significant difference in this regard (P < 0.001). Thus, repeated-measures ANOVA was applied with ΔE1 as the reaped measure, which showed that the result of Mauchly's sphericity test was significant (P < 0.001).
Repeated-measures ANOVA showed that time had a significant effect on color change (P = 0.001). Furthermore, this test showed that the interaction effect of time and type of cement on color change was not statistically significant (P = 0.308). Color change over time was not dependent on the type of cement used in any group [Table 1].
|Table 1: The mean and standard deviation of color change in the four groups|
Click here to view
Tests of between-subjects effects among the three groups showed no significant difference (P = 0.343). Bonferroni test was applied for pairwise comparison of time points, which showed significant differences between each 2 time points (P < 0.01) except for ΔE4 and ΔE5 (P > 0.05).
| Discussion|| |
This in vitro study compared the coronal discoloration of white MTA, CEM cement, and Biodentine within 3 months in human teeth. Although some previous studies compared discoloration of each of these cement alone or in comparison with other materials, comparison of all three together has not been previously performed.
Only premolar teeth were evaluated in this study in order to have approximately the same thickness of dentin in all teeth. Furthermore, considering the greater clinical significance of discoloration in the esthetic zone, extracted human premolars were chosen since they are located in the esthetic zone.
In order to prevent discoloration due to gutta-percha and AH26 sealer, gutta-percha was cut at the level of orifice and pulp chamber was thoroughly cleaned from gutta-percha and sealer residues using a cotton pellet dipped in alcohol. Next, the respective cement were directly placed on gutta-percha in 3 mm thickness. Although in vital pulp therapy, the cement are directly placed on pulp tissue and exert their specific clinical effects, it has been documented that discoloration caused in vitro by application of these cement in endodontically treated teeth is the same as discoloration in teeth with vital pulp.
The CIE L*a*b* color system was used in this study for color assessment, which has been approved by the American Dental Association and is the most accurate and most commonly used system for colorimetry. Spectrophotometric measurements were made under standard lighting conditions as recommended to benefit from maximum precision provided by this system.
Evidence shows that time is an important factor affecting discoloration caused by different materials; this statement was also confirmed in the current study. Our results showed significant discoloration in all groups over time compared to baseline (P < 0.001). However, color change was not significantly different at 2 and 3 months (P > 0.05). Vallés et al. evaluated the effect of light irradiation and presence of oxygen on color stability of five calcium silicate-based cement during 5 days and Camilleri compared discoloration of MTA and Biodentine (not applied on tooth structure) during 28 days. Both studies reported optimal color stability of Biodentine, which may be attributed to short course of the two studies because a previous study by Shokouhinejad et al. reported coronal discoloration at 6 months following the application of Biodentine. On the other hand, Marconyak et al., and Beatty and Svec in their 2-month study reported less discoloration caused by Biodentine compared to white MTA. However, in our study, tooth discoloration caused by Biodentine was not significantly different from that of White MTA at 3 months.
Arman et al. evaluated coronal discoloration caused by CEM cement and MTA after 6 months and reported that discoloration caused by the two cement was equal. Eghbal et al. compared CEM cement and MTA in terms of tooth discoloration after 28 days and reported that CEM cement caused less discoloration than MTA. Findings of the current study revealed that discoloration caused by CEM cement and MTA was the same, which is in contrast to the results of Eghbal et al. This controversy in the results may be due to time of assessment (28 days in their study versus 3 months in ours).
Vallés et al. stated that reaction of bismuth with oxygen in the presence of light is responsible for tooth discoloration caused by white MTA, which results in formation of bismuth oxide crystals. These crystals darken the tooth color and their formation in the presence of visible and ultraviolet light has been documented. Considering the fact that, in our study, the teeth were exposed to natural light during the storage phase, conditions required for formation of the above-mentioned crystals and subsequent discoloration of tooth structure were met. Our results with regard to discoloration caused by white MTA were in line with those of previous studies.,,,
Over time, a significant discoloration occurred in CEM cement group in our study (P < 0.001), which was not significantly different from discoloration in white MTA and Biodentine groups (P = 0.343). This finding was in line with the results of Arman et al., in their study on 32 dentin-enamel blocks of maxillary incisors. However, Eghbal et al. reported that CEM cement had higher color stability than white MTA. Such a controversy in the results of studies may be attributed not only to the effect of time but also to the effect of environment on degree of coronal discoloration.
Nosrat et al. claimed that application of CEM cement at the orifice does not cause tooth discoloration (in contrast to MTA). Madani et al. reported that tooth discoloration caused by CEM cement was minimal. However, the two aforementioned studies had not been designed to assess tooth discoloration.
Ioannidis et al. reported that coronal discoloration in gray MTA and white MTA. Mean (SD) ΔE values after 3rd month were 7.47 (2.22) and 4.26 (1.90) for gray MTA and white MTA, respectively. This value in our study was higher which can be due to the different method of work.
Nosrat et al. reported treatment of two cases with revascularization and Madani et al. evaluated histopathological pulp responses following the application of CEM cement and MTA in diabetic rats.
In our study, teeth in Biodentine group showed significant discoloration during 3 months (P < 0.001), which was not significantly different from discoloration in MTA and CEM cement groups (P > 0.01). Shokouhinejad et al. evaluated tooth discoloration following the application of different calcium silicate-based cement and reported that in the presence of blood, all cement caused similar tooth discoloration while in the absence of blood, tooth discoloration caused by Biodentine and Endosequence was less than that caused by OrthoMTA. These findings were in contrast to our results, which may probably be due to the different types of MTA cement evaluated in the two studies. Kohli et al. reported no discoloration due to the application of Biodentine but showed that white MTA caused discoloration in tooth structure, which was different from our results. This difference between the results of the two studies may be explained by different methodologies and tools used for colorimetry since they stored teeth at 37°C and used ocean optics device for spectrophotometry.
| Conclusion|| |
All three endodontic cement evaluated in this study can cause coronal discoloration. The three tested cement are not significantly different in terms of the degree of color change caused in tooth structure following their application. Significant differences were noted in color change (ΔE) between all time points except between ΔE4 (2 months) and ΔE5 (3 months).
Financial support and sponsorship
The authors gratefully acknowledge the Research Council of Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences (Grant Number: 94450) for the financial support. This work was performed in partial fulfillment of the requirements for Doctoral Degree in Dentistry of Mahshid Saedipour, in Faculty of Dentistry, Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences, Kermanshah, Iran.
Conflicts of interest
The authors of this manuscript declare that they have no conflicts of interest, real or perceived, financial or nonfinancial in this article.
| References|| |
Shabahang S. Treatment options: Apexogenesis and apexification. J Endod 2013;39:S26-9.
Berman LH. Endodontic prognosis assessment. Alpha Omegan 2011;104:12-7.
Li Z, Cao L, Fan M, Xu Q. Direct pulp capping with calcium hydroxide or mineral trioxide aggregate: A Meta-analysis. J Endod 2015;41:1412-7.
Lenherr P, Allgayer N, Weiger R, Filippi A, Attin T, Krastl G, et al.
Tooth discoloration induced by endodontic materials: A laboratory study. Int Endod J 2012;45:942-9.
Camilleri J. Staining potential of neo MTA plus, MTA plus, and biodentine used for pulpotomy procedures. J Endod 2015;41:1139-45.
Jang JH, Kang M, Ahn S, Kim S, Kim W, Kim Y, et al.
Tooth discoloration after the use of new pozzolan cement (Endocem) and mineral trioxide aggregate and the effects of internal bleaching. J Endod 2013;39:1598-602.
Malkondu Ö, Karapinar Kazandağ M, Kazazoğlu E. A review on biodentine, a contemporary dentine replacement and repair material. Biomed Res Int 2014;2014:160951.
Asgary S, Eghbal MJ, Parirokh M. Sealing ability of a novel endodontic cement as a root-end filling material. J Biomed Mater Res A 2008;87:706-9.
Parirokh M, Torabinejad M. Mineral trioxide aggregate: A comprehensive literature review-part I: Chemical, physical, and antibacterial properties. J Endod 2010;36:16-27.
Arman M, Khalilak Z, Rajabi M, Esnaashari E, Saati K.In vitro
spectrophotometry of tooth discoloration induced by tooth-colored mineral trioxide aggregate and calcium-enriched mixture cement. Iran Endod J 2015;10:226-30.
Fabbri G, Mancini R, Marinelli V, Ban G. Anterior discolored teeth restored with procera all-ceramic restorations: A clinical evaluation of the esthetic outcome based on the thickness of the core selected. Eur J Esthet Dent 2011;6:76-86.
Felman D, Parashos P. Coronal tooth discoloration and white mineral trioxide aggregate. J Endod 2013;39:484-7.
Vailati F, Gruetter L, Belser UC. Adhesively restored anterior maxillary dentitions affected by severe erosion: Up to 6-year results of a prospective clinical study. Eur J Esthet Dent 2013;8:506-30.
Dahl JE, Pallesen U. Tooth bleaching-a critical review of the biological aspects. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med 2003;14:292-304.
Cavenago BC, Pereira TC, Duarte MA, Ordinola-Zapata R, Marciano MA, Bramante CM, et al.
Influence of powder-to-water ratio on radiopacity, setting time, pH, calcium ion release and a micro-CT volumetric solubility of white mineral trioxide aggregate. Int Endod J 2014;47:120-6.
Krastl G, Allgayer N, Lenherr P, Filippi A, Taneja P, Weiger R, et al.
Tooth discoloration induced by endodontic materials: A literature review. Dent Traumatol 2013;29:2-7.
Mori GG, Teixeira LM, de Oliveira DL, Jacomini LM, da Silva SR. Biocompatibility evaluation of biodentine in subcutaneous tissue of rats. J Endod 2014;40:1485-8.
Parirokh M, Torabinejad M. Mineral trioxide aggregate: A comprehensive literature review-part III: Clinical applications, drawbacks, and mechanism of action. J Endod 2010;36:400-13.
Prati C, Gandolfi MG. Calcium silicate bioactive cements: Biological perspectives and clinical applications. Dent Mater 2015;31:351-70.
Elnaghy AM. Influence of acidic environment on properties of biodentine and white mineral trioxide aggregate: A comparative study. J Endod 2014;40:953-7.
Akbari M, Rouhani A, Samiee S, Jafarzadeh H. Effect of dentin bonding agent on the prevention of tooth discoloration produced by mineral trioxide aggregate. Int J Dent 2012;2012:563203.
Ioannidis K, Mistakidis I, Beltes P, Karagiannis V. Spectrophotometric analysis of coronal discolouration induced by grey and white MTA. Int Endod J 2013;46:137-44.
Berger T, Baratz AZ, Gutmann JL.In vitro
investigations into the etiology of mineral trioxide tooth staining. J Conserv Dent 2014;17:526-30. [Full text]
Vallés M, Mercadé M, Duran-Sindreu F, Bourdelande JL, Roig M. Color stability of white mineral trioxide aggregate. Clin Oral Investig 2013;17:1155-9.
Vallés M, Roig M, Duran-Sindreu F, Martínez S, Mercadé M. Color stability of teeth restored with biodentine: A 6-month in vitro
study. J Endod 2015;41:1157-60.
Beatty H, Svec T. Quantifying coronal tooth discoloration caused by biodentine and endoSequence root repair material. J Endod 2015;41:2036-9.
Shokouhinejad N, Nekoofar MH, Pirmoazen S, Shamshiri AR, Dummer PM. Evaluation and comparison of occurrence of tooth discoloration after the application of various calcium silicate-based cements: An ex vivo
study. J Endod 2016;42:140-4.
Asgary S, Shahabi S, Jafarzadeh T, Amini S, Kheirieh S. The properties of a new endodontic material. J Endod 2008;34:990-3.
Esnaashari E, Pezeshkfar A, Fazlyab M. Nonsurgical management of an extensive perforative internal root resorption with calcium-enriched mixture cement. Iran Endod J 2015;10:75-8.
Madani ZS, Haddadi A, Mesgarani A, Seyedmajidi M, Mostafazadeh A, Bijani A, et al.
Histopathologic responses of the dental pulp to calcium-enriched mixture (CEM) and mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) in diabetic and non-diabetic rats. Int J Mol Cell Med 2014;3:263-71.
Marconyak LJ Jr. Kirkpatrick TC, Roberts HW, Roberts MD, Aparicio A, Himel VT, et al.
Acomparison of coronal tooth discoloration elicited by Various endodontic reparative materials. J Endod 2016;42:470-3.
Eghbal MJ, Torabzadeh H, Bagheban AA, Shamszadeh S, Marvasti LA, Asgary S, et al.
Color stability of mineral trioxide aggregate and calcium enriched mixture cement. J Investig Clin Dent 2016;7:341-6.
Vallés M, Mercadé M, Duran-Sindreu F, Bourdelande JL, Roig M. Influence of light and oxygen on the color stability of five calcium silicate-based materials. J Endod 2013;39:525-8.
Marciano MA, Costa RM, Camilleri J, Mondelli RF, Guimarães BM, Duarte MA, et al.
Assessment of color stability of white mineral trioxide aggregate angelus and bismuth oxide in contact with tooth structure. J Endod 2014;40:1235-40.
Nosrat A, Seifi A, Asgary S. Regenerative endodontic treatment (revascularization) for necrotic immature permanent molars: A review and report of two cases with a new biomaterial. J Endod 2011;37:562-7.
Kohli MR, Yamaguchi M, Setzer FC, Karabucak B. Spectrophotometric analysis of coronal tooth discoloration induced by various bioceramic cements and other endodontic materials. J Endod 2015;41:1862-6.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]