|Year : 2021 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 31
Effect of citric acid on force decay of orthodontic elastomeric chains
Amin Khaleghi1, Atefe Ahmadvand1, Saeid Sadeghian2
1 Department of Orthodontics, Research Committee, School of Dentistry, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
2 Department of Orthodontics, Dental Research Center, Dental Research Institute, School of Dentistry, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
|Date of Submission||08-Nov-2019|
|Date of Acceptance||19-Sep-2020|
|Date of Web Publication||24-May-2021|
Dr. Saeid Sadeghian
Department of Orthodontics, Dental Research Center, School of Dentistry, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Hezar Jarib Street, Isfahan
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: This study aimed to assess the effect of citric acid, as a weak acid commonly used in food industry, on elastomeric chain force decay.
Materials and Methods: In this in vitro, experimental study, sixty elastomeric chains from two commercial brands of American Orthodontics and Ortho Technology (n = 30) were cut into five-piece segments. Elastomeric chains of each brand were randomly divided into two groups of control (artificial saliva) and citric acid. All elastomeric chains were incubated in artificial saliva at 37°C. Experimental samples were immersed in 10 mL of citric acid for 90 s daily and were then transferred back to the artificial saliva. The elastomeric chain force was measured at baseline (before the experiment), 1 day, 1 week, 2 weeks, and 3 weeks using an electromechanical universal testing machine. Data were analyzed using t-test, Kruskal–Wallis test, and Mann–Whitney U-test at 0.05 level of significance.
Results: The elastomeric chain force gradually degraded over time. The difference in this respect was not significant at 2 and 3 weeks in any group (P > 0.05). On initiation of the experiment, the force in the citric acid group experienced a greater decay than that in the control group; the difference between the citric acid and control groups in both the brands was significant at all time points until the end of the 3rd week (P < 0.05). The difference between the American Orthodontics and Ortho Technology brands in the control and citric acid groups was significant at all time points (P < 0.001).
Conclusion: Elastomeric chains in both the citric acid and artificial saliva groups experienced force decay over time. Force decay was greater in the citric acid group. Thus, citric acid can effectively decrease the elastomeric chain force. The Ortho Technology chain force was higher than that of American Orthodontics in both the groups at all time points.
Keywords: Biodegradation, citric acid, elastomeric
|How to cite this article:|
Khaleghi A, Ahmadvand A, Sadeghian S. Effect of citric acid on force decay of orthodontic elastomeric chains. Dent Res J 2021;18:31
| Introduction|| |
Elastomeric chains are used in orthodontics for many purposes such as space closure. They are extensively used due to low cost, being hygienic and easy application., Despite the advantages of elastomeric chains, their properties are often affected by heat and moisture. The main drawback of elastomeric chains is their force decay due to the breakage of cross-links between the long-chain molecules during clinical application.
It has been reported that elastomeric chains lose a great portion of their force (around 50%–70%) within the first 24 h of use, and this force decay continues at a slower pace in the next 3–4 weeks and can be influenced by a number of factors.,, Rapid force decay in elastomeric chains results in inadequate tooth movement, necessitating additional appointments for activation of the appliance.
The level of elastomeric chain force depends on several factors such as the materials used by the manufacturer for their fabrication, dyes added to the chains, form of the chain (open or closed), being subjected to tension before use, sterilization techniques, storage techniques, environmental factors such as tooth movement, thermal alterations, acidity of the environment, use of mouthwashes, salivary enzymes, and masticatory forces. The abovementioned factors can all affect the trend of force decay and relaxation behavior of elastomeric chains.
Oral cavity has a complex environment, and orthodontic appliances in the oral cavity are subjected to thermal, chemical, and mechanical alterations over long periods of time, which may result in their degradation. The effect of environmental factors on the pattern of force decay of elastomeric chains has been previously evaluated., Salivary enzymes and masticatory forces change the properties of elastomeric chains., The effect of different environmental factors such as pH and thermal alterations and the effects of commonly consumed drinks on the properties of elastomeric materials have also been studied.,,,
Citric acid is a naturally occurring weak organic acid found in all citrus fruits and vegetables. It is used widely as an acidulant and pH regulator. Furthermore, it is added to foods and drinks as a flavor enhancer, preservative and antioxidant synergist. It has been approved by the FAO/WHO as a safe additive and is, therefore, extensively used in the food industry.
This in vitro study aimed to assess the effect of citric acid on elastomeric chain force decay. In case of finding a positive effect, orthodontic patients should be advised to decrease the consumption of products containing citric acid.
| Materials and Methods|| |
In this in vitro, experimental study, a total of 60 short elastomeric chains from two major manufacturers, namely American Orthodontics (Sheboygan, Wisconsin, USA) and Ortho Technology (Tampa, Florida, USA) were selected (n = 30 from each brand). They were then cut into five-piece segments. To prevent possible damage to the chains during the process of cutting, the sections were made at the center of adjacent links at the two ends of the five-piece segments such that at each end of the five-piece segment, a half-link was present [Figure 1]a. The segments from each brand were then randomly divided into two groups of control (artificial saliva) and citric acid. Thus, the following four groups were evaluated in this study:
|Figure 1: (a and b) Chains connected to the fixtures. (c) Electromechanical universal testing machine for measurement of chain force.|
Click here to view
- Group 1: American Orthodontics chains immersed in artificial saliva
- Group 2: American Orthodontics chains immersed in citric acid
- Group 3: Ortho Technology chains immersed in artificial saliva
- Group 4: Ortho Technology chains immersed in citric acid.
To simulate the oral environment, all samples were immersed in artificial saliva (Hypozalix, Biocodex, France) and incubated at 37°C. The composition of artificial saliva included water, MgCl2, NaCl, and cellulose materials with a pH of 7.2 and 110 cps viscosity. Aqueous solution of 0.001 M citric acid with a pH of 2.3 was used to simulate acidic conditions. This solution is commonly used as an external acid in laboratory models of dental erosion. The samples were immersed in 10 mL of citric acid solution for 90 s and were then transferred back to artificial saliva.
The details of the procedure in the two groups were as follows:
- Groups 1 and 3 (control group): Elastomeric chains in these two groups were only immersed in artificial saliva and incubated at 37°C
- Groups 2 and 4 (citric acid): Elastomeric chains in these two groups were removed from the artificial saliva on a daily basis and immersed in citric acid solution for 90 s. After removal from the citric acid solution, they were transferred back to the artificial saliva.
To measure the magnitude of force generated by the chains, two stainless steel metal fixtures were mounted in self-cure acrylic resin [Figure 1]b. The diameter of the fixtures was 1.2 mm and the distance between the two fixtures was 25 mm to simulate the distance between the hook of a first molar and the distal wing of a canine tooth bracket in the clinical setting. In this distance, chains apply 100–300 g force, which is suitable for canine tooth retraction. The chains were positioned between the two fixtures.
The force generated by the chains was measured at five time points, namely at baseline (before the experiment), 1 day, 1 week, 2 weeks, and 3 weeks using an electromechanical universal testing machine (K-21046, Switzerland) [Figure 1]c and reported in Newtons (N). The study period was 3 weeks. Orthodontic appointments are often scheduled every 3 or 4 weeks to replace the elastomeric chains. Thus, some studies evaluated the behavior of these materials for a period of 21 days.,,
All measurements were made at room temperature. Forceps designed for this purpose was used to transfer the elastomeric chain between the fixtures to the universal testing machine. The forceps would open by 25 mm so that all samples received a similar level of tension. The machine had two major probes. The study probes were mounted on the two major probes of the machine after being designed and manufactured. The minor probes were opened by 25 mm (corresponding to the distance between the two fixtures), and the force generated by the chain was displayed on the monitor. Considering the variations and alterations in force during the first few seconds of mounting of chains on the machine, a 10-s time period was allowed after mounting of the chains on the probes and then the force was measured.
The t-test was used to compare the two brands and the citric acid and artificial saliva groups. The Kruskal–Wallis test and the Mann–Whitney U-test were applied for the comparison of different time points. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
| Results|| |
As shown in [Figure 2], elastomeric chain force gradually degraded in all the groups during the 3 weeks such that the difference in force in all the groups between baseline and 24 h and 1 week and 2 weeks was significant (P < 0.001). The difference in force measured at 2 and 3 weeks was not significant in any group (P > 0.05).
|Figure 2: American Orthodontics and Ortho Technology elastomeric chain force in the artificial saliva and citric acid groups.|
Click here to view
As shown in [Table 1], no significant difference was noted in force between the two groups of control and citric acid in any of the two brands (P > 0.05). After initiating the experiment, the force in the citric acid group experienced greater decay compared with the control group, and the difference in this respect between the two groups was significant at all time points until the end of the 3rd week in both the brands (P < 0.05). The difference between the American Orthodontics and Ortho Technology in the control and citric acid groups was significant at all time points (P < 0.001).
|Table 1: Comparison of American Orthodontics and Ortho Technology elastomeric chain force in the control and citric acid groups at different time points|
Click here to view
The mean elastomeric chain force of the groups measured at five time points is shown in [Figure 2] and [Table 2].
|Table 2: Mean elastomeric chain force of the four groups measured at five time points|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Elastomeric chains are extensively used in orthodontics for tooth movement and space closure. However, their force decay is inevitable. Sensitivity of elastomeric chains to alterations in the oral environment is the most important cause of their plastic deformation and force decay. Acids produced by the oral bacteria and acids present in foods and drinks are important environmental factors that affect the physical and mechanical properties of elastomeric chains. This study aimed to assess the effect of citric acid on elastomeric chain force decay.
The shape and size of elastomeric chains (short, moderate, or long) also affect their mechanical properties. Short chains were evaluated in this study since they retain a higher percentage of force overtime. Furthermore, the chains were cut into five-piece segments; evidence shows that this particular length of a short elastomeric chain provides the required tension for retraction of canine in case of extraction of premolars and is suitable for the 25-mm distance between the canine and first molar teeth.
Force decay tests that are performed at room temperature under dry conditions are weak representatives of oral clinical conditions, and the displayed force values by these tests are different from the actual chain forces in water, artificial saliva, aqueous environments, and distilled water. Thus, in the present study, the samples were immersed in artificial saliva and incubated at 37°C to simulate the clinical setting.
In the present study, the exposure time of chains to acid was 90 s, which corresponds to the time it takes for the pH to drop following the consumption of foods containing citric acid.
In this study, the initial force (10 s) values ranged from 366 ± 13 g to 282 ± 12 g. However, after 24 h, the force levels of all elastic chains ranged from 159 ± 42 g to 98 ± 10 g. This shows a 56%–65% force decay that is in agreement with prior studies that reported 50%–70% force decay after 24 h.,, Such differences are clinically important because 100–300 g forces are clinically acceptable for movement of a group of teeth or a single tooth.
However, the subsequent force decay of the tested chains was more important than the initial force levels. The current results showed that the chain force in all the groups gradually decreased within 3 weeks such that in all the groups, significant differences were noted between the values at baseline, 24 h, 1 week, and 2 weeks. These results were in agreement with the results of previous studies that showed that passage of time was a factor that caused a reduction in chain force.,,,
Water is known as a factor causing a reduction in elastomeric chain force as well. The reason is the affinity between the hydrogen atoms in the water molecule and oxygen atoms in the chain. This affinity results in water sorption by the polymer chain. The absorbed water creates a space in the polymer chain and expands the gaps. The polymer can absorb water to a certain amount until reaching a peak. In this study, the difference in the magnitude of force at 2 and 3 weeks was not significant in any group, which can be probably due to the fact that water sorption by the chains reached its peak.
At baseline, there was no significant difference in chain force between the control and citric acid groups in any brand. After initiation of the experiment, the magnitude of force in the citric acid group experienced a greater reduction compared with that in the control group, and the difference between the two groups was significant in both the brands at all time points until the end of the 3-week study period. This finding indicates that citric acid can effectively decrease the elastomeric chain force. This finding was in agreement with the result of Nattrass et al., who suggested that acidity can cause force decay. However, our result in this respect was in contrast to those of Suprayugo et al., Santos et al., and Teixeira et al., who believed that acidity cannot effectively decrease elastomeric chain force.,, Furthermore, this result was in contrast to the findings of Ferriter et al. and Pithon et al., who reported a smaller reduction in force of elastomeric chains stored in environments with higher acidity., The difference between our results and those of the abovementioned studies can be due to the different environments used in each study. Suprayugo et al. and Pithon et al. immersed the elastomeric chains in soft drinks, which may contain other additives and compounds. Thus, the results cannot be directly attributed to the acidity of the solutions. Santos et al. and Ferriter et al. used environments with higher pH than our study. The same results could be obtained in lower pH values.
Elastomeric chains of different brands show variable degrees of reduction in force, which may be attributed to their different manufacturing processes such as printing system, raw materials, additive chemical agents, and shape and size of the loops. In the present study, the magnitude of force of Ortho Technology elastomeric chains in both the control and citric acid groups was significantly higher than the corresponding value in American Orthodontics elastomeric chains at all time points.
It is important to know the magnitude of primary force that elastomeric chains of each manufacturer can retain since knowledge in this respect enables the dental clinicians to initiate treatment with a more suitable magnitude of force that lasts and maintains a minimum desired value until the next appointment session. In this study, the American Orthodontics elastomeric chains immersed in citric acid showed a considerable decrease in the amount of force generated after 24 h. Considering the force value required for orthodontic movement, the American Orthodontics elastomeric chains immersed in citric acid after 24 h, the American Orthodontics elastomeric chains immersed in artificial saliva after 1 week, and the Ortho Technology elastomeric chains immersed in both citric acid and artificial saliva after 2 weeks with remaining force <100 g, lost their effectiveness to close the spaces. Therefore, the Ortho Technology elastomeric chains presented better results in this study.
One of the main limitations in analyzing the results of this study was lack of similar in vivo studies. One of the limitations of in vitro studies including this one is that the fluctuations of intraoral temperature and acidity due to the consumption of different foods and beverages cannot be simulated in vitro. Although in vitro studies are valuable, direct generalization of their results to the clinical situations should be performed with caution. Despite these limitations, this study provided the orthodontists with additional information regarding some considerations that need to be taken into account by orthodontic patients such as limiting the consumption of fruits and vegetables containing citric acid during the appliance activation period by the use of elastomeric chains.
| Conclusion|| |
Elastomeric chains experienced force decay following immersion in artificial saliva and citric acid overtime. After the study onset, the magnitude of force in the citric acid group experienced greater decay, which indicates that citric acid can effectively cause elastomeric force decay. The magnitude of force of Ortho Technology elastomeric chains in both the citric acid and artificial saliva groups was significantly higher than that of American Orthodontics elastomeric chains at all time points.
Financial support and sponsorship
Conflicts of interest
The authors of this manuscript declare that they have no conflicts of interest, real or perceived, financial or non-financial in this article.
| References|| |
Halimi A, Azeroual MF, Doukkali A, El Mabrouk K, Zaoui F. Elastomeric chain force decay in artificial saliva: An in vitro
study. Int Orthod 2013;11:60-70.
Santos AC, Tortamano A, Naccarato SR, Dominguez-Rodriguez GC, Vigorito JW. An in vitro
comparison of the force decay generated by different commercially available elastomeric chains and NiTi closed coil springs. Braz Oral Res 2007;21:51-7.
Notaroberto DF, Martins MM, Goldner MT, Mendes AM, Quintão CC. Force decay evaluation of latex and non-latex orthodontic intraoral elastics: In vivo
study. Dental Press J Orthod 2018;23:42-7.
Mohammed H, Rizk M, Wafaie K, Almuzian M. Effectiveness of nickel-titanium springs vs. elastomeric chains in orthodontic space closure: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Orthod Craniofac Res 2018;21:12-9.
Singh M. Effect on mechanical properties of orthodontic elastomeric ligatures on immersion in disinfecting solutions – An in vitro
study. J Adv Med Med Res 2016;18:1-9.
Menon VV, Madhavan S, Chacko T, Gopalakrishnan S, Jacob J, Parayancode A. Comparative Assessment of Force Decay of the Elastomeric Chain With the Use of Various Mouth Rinses in Simulated Oral Environment: An In Vitro
Study. Journal of Pharmacy & Bioallied Sciences. 2019 May;11(Suppl 2): 269-73.
Losito KA, Lucato AS, Tubel CA, Correa CA, Santos JC. Force decay in orthodontic elastomeric chains after immersion in disinfection solutions. Braz J Oral Sci 2014;13:266-9.
Oshagh M, Khajeh F, Heidari S, Torkan S, Fattahi HR. The effect of different environmental factors on force degradation of three common systems of orthodontic space closure. Dent Res J (Isfahan) 2015;12:50-6.
von Fraunhofer JA, Coffelt MT, Orbell GM. The effects of artificial saliva and topical fluoride treatments on the degradation of the elastic properties of orthodontic chains. Angle Orthod 1992;62:265-74.
Josell SD, Leiss JB, Rekow ED, editors. Force degradation in elastomeric chains. Seminars in orthodontics; 1997;3(3):189-97. [PMID: 9573880].
Jaber LC, Rodrigues JA, Amaral FL, França FM, Basting RT, Turssi CP. Degradation of orthodontic wires under simulated cariogenic and erosive conditions. Braz Oral Res 2014;28:1-6.
Shaddud A, Kosyreva T. The effect of environmental factors on elastomeric chains and nickel titanium coil springs. RUDN J Med 2017;21:339-46.
Javanmardi Z, Salehi P. Effects of orthokin, sensikin and PERSICA mouth rinses on the force degradation of elastic chains and NiTi coil springs. J Dent Res Dent Clin Dent Prospects 2016;10:99-105.
Kamisetty SK, Nimagadda C, Begam MP, Nalamotu R, Srivastav T, Gs S. Elasticity in elastics – An in vitro
study. J Int Oral Health 2014;6:96-105.
Patel A, Thomas B. In vivo
evaluation of the force degradation characteristics of four contemporarily used elastomeric chains over a period of 6 weeks. J World Fed Orthod 2018;7:141-5.
Sulaiman T, Eriwati YK, Indrani DJ. Effect of temperature on tensile force of orthodontics power chain in artificial saliva solution. J Physics 2018;1073:62006.
Suprayugo M, Eriwati YK, Santosa A. Effect of pH of soft drinks on force decay in orthodontic power chains. J Physics 2018;1073:62016.
Braga E, Souza G, Barretto P, Ferraz C, Pithon M. Experimental evaluation of strength degradation of orthodontic chain elastics immersed in hot beverages. J Indian Orthod Soc 2019;53:244-8.
Shailaja A, Santosh R, Vedhavathi H, Keerthi N, Kumar SP. Assessment of the force decay and the influence of pH levels on three different brands of latex and non-latex orthodontic elastics: An in vitro
study. Int J Applied Dent Sci 2016;2:28-34.
Penniston KL, Nakada SY, Holmes RP, Assimos DG. Quantitative assessment of citric acid in lemon juice, lime juice, and commercially-available fruit juice products. J Endourol 2008;22:567-70.
Yılmaz S, Unal F, Yüzbaşıoğlu D, Aksoy H. Clastogenic effects of food additive citric acid in human peripheral lymphocytes. Cytotechnology 2008;56:137-44.
Joint FA, WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives, World Health Organization. Toxicological Evaluation of Certain Food Additives with a Review of General Principles and of Specifications: Seventeenth Report of the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives. Geneva: World Health Organization; 1973.
Weissheimer A, Locks A, de Menezes LM, Borgatto AF, Derech CD. In vitro
evaluation of force degradation of elastomeric chains used in orthodontics. Dental Press J Orthod 2013;18:55-62.
Teixeira L, Pereira Bdo R, Bortoly TG, Brancher JA, Tanaka OM, Guariza-Filho O. The environmental influence of Light Coke, phosphoric acid, and citric acid on elastomeric chains. J Contemp Dent Pract 2008;9:17-24.
De Genova DC, McInnes-Ledoux P, Weinberg R, Shaye R. Force degradation of orthodontic elastomeric chains – A product comparison study. Am J Orthod 1985;87:377-84.
Eliades T, Bourauel C. Intraoral aging of orthodontic materials: The picture we miss and its clinical relevance. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2005;127:403-12.
Eliades T, Eliades G, Silikas N, Watts DC. Tensile properties of orthodontic elastomeric chains. Eur J Orthod 2004;26:157-62.
Araujo FB, Ursi WJ. Study of degradation caused by synthetic orthodontic elastics. Rev Dent Press Ortod Ortopedia Fac 2006;11:52-61.
Kim KH, Chung CH, Choy K, Lee JS, Vanarsdall RL. Effects of prestretching on force degradation of synthetic elastomeric chains. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2005;128:477-82.
Tenuta LM, Fernández CE, Brandão AC, Cury JA. Titratable acidity of beverages influences salivary pH recovery. Braz Oral Res 2015;29:1-6.
Millward A, Shaw L, Harrington E, Smith AJ. Continuous monitoring of salivary flow rate and pH at the surface of the dentition following consumption of acidic beverages. Caries Res 1997;31:44-9.
Masoud AI, Tsay TP, BeGole E, Bedran-Russo AK. Force decay evaluation of thermoplastic and thermoset elastomeric chains: A mechanical design comparison. Angle Orthod 2014;84:1026-33.
Wong AK. Orthodontic elastic materials. Angle Orthod 1976;46:196-205.
Ferriter JP, Meyers CE Jr., Lorton L. The effect of hydrogen ion concentration on the force-degradation rate of orthodontic polyurethane chain elastics. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 1990;98:404-10.
Eliades T, Eliades G, Watts DC. Structural conformation of in vitro
and in vivo
aged orthodontic elastomeric modules. Eur J Orthod 1999;21:649-58.
Baschek G, Hartwig G, Zahradnik F. Effect of water absorption in polymers at low and high temperatures. Polymer 1999;40:3433-41.
Nattrass C, Ireland AJ, Sherriff M. The effect of environmental factors on elastomeric chain and nickel titanium coil springs. Eur J Orthod 1998;20:169-76.
Santos RL, Pithon MM, Romanos MT. The effect of different pH levels on conventional vs. super-force chain elastics. Mater Res 2013;16:246-51.
Pithon MM, Lacerda-Santos R, Santana LR, Rocha M, Leal RO, Santos MM. Does acidic drinks vs. controls differents interfere with the force of orthodontic chain elastics? Biosci J 2014;30:1952-8.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2]
[Table 1], [Table 2]